Skip to Content

Pros and Cons of Investing in an Older Home as a Rental Property

A charming older brick home with a spacious driveway and a lush garden in front.
Investing in older single-family homes to be used as rental property can be a fruitful strategy. It is essential to understand that there are many pros and cons to choosing older homes instead of new ones. For instance, older homes frequently boast a great location, lower purchase prices, and a more stable market rate that can be appealing to investors.
However, there are significant downsides to buying an older home, including a higher cost of repairs and improvements, potential lower energy efficiency, and the risk of losing widespread renter appeal. When searching for your next investment property, both the pros and cons should be considered carefully before making any final decisions.

Benefits of Older Rental Homes: Prime Locations and Steady Income

There are numerous benefits to purchasing older homes to use as rental properties. One of the most substantial benefits an older home provides is its location. Unlike newer homes that tend to be situated far from the area’s best amenities, older homes are often found within a short distance of desirable social and commercial areas.
For Millennial renters, young professionals, or seniors looking to enjoy their retirement, a rental home with easy access to the city center or local attractions can be a strong incentive. Older properties are often located in established neighborhoods, typically characterized by more predictable rental rates. The ability to reliably forecast your rental income is one of the key benefits of buying an older home, enabling better financial planning and investment strategies.

 

In many areas, older homes offer the benefit of being more affordable than new construction. This affordability can significantly lower the upfront cost of the property and allow investors to maintain control over how much is spent on necessary improvements or upgrades. While it is likely that an older home will require some renovations, investors can control costs by undertaking some of the work themselves or by scheduling projects strategically to maximize cash flow.

Depending on the age and condition of the home, investors may also be able to rely on higher-quality construction and a more traditional floor plan. Such features may appeal to certain demographics, particularly renters looking for a home with a unique look or feel.

Drawbacks of Older Rental Homes: Costly Updates and Maintenance

While the many benefits can make older homes attractive for investors across the country, it is crucial to acknowledge that there are also notable drawbacks. Older homes tend to have outdated heating and cooling systems, along with potential plumbing and wiring issues that can arise.

These properties may also have code compliance challenges, which can lead to costly repairs and renovations. Windows in older homes are often less energy efficient than those found in newer constructions, which can result in higher energy bills and difficulties for renters trying to control the temperature inside the house.

 

Unlike essential maintenance and repairs, older homes carry the risk of expensive updates and improvements to make the home both safe for occupants and attractive to potential tenants. The higher upfront costs that result may put a short-term strain on your cash flow, making it important for investors to feel confident about funding repairs, big or small.

 

Assessing Older Homes for Potential Issues

Another potential disadvantage of buying an older home could involve the composition of the neighborhood. Gathering detailed information about a neighborhood before purchasing is essential, as it can provide insights into potential risks and rewards. Check carefully for signs of neglect, as these can indicate future challenges.
Often, the area surrounding the home you select may be due for a water main or sewer line upgrade, which typically comes with a hefty special assessment or tax to the owner that can be due immediately. If the area is in decline, property prices may seem low, but this might also indicate that the home’s expected future market value is not as promising as one would hope.

Older houses can make excellent investment properties, but they can also become a financial drain for investors if not managed effectively. Although old houses present many features that newer homes do not, careful evaluations and market assessments are necessary to mitigate risks associated with potential repairs and renovations.

At Real Property Management Titan, we are here to assist investors in evaluating and vetting potential rental properties. We provide comprehensive information regarding the home’s neighborhood and the local rental market in Nashville and nearby areas. Our commitment lies in helping real estate investors make the best possible investment decisions tailored to their financial goals. Contact us online or call 615-538-7711 for more information about how we can support you in your investment journey!

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details